So when it came time to replace La Russa, who ranks third on the all-time managerial list in both games won (5,097) and postseason appearances (six), Mozeliak threw the baseball world a curve.
He hired Mike Matheny, a 41-year-old former big league catcher, who had been spending his time since a concussion-forced retirement in 2006 by working with youth teams, and doing some work in the Cardinals' farm system helping develop catchers.
"One of the things that had to be considered in hiring the replacement to Tony La Russa is finding somehow who understood the culture we developed and how things go down here," said Mozeliak. "Mike had been part of the organization as a player [for five years] and an instructor. He had a good relationship with our staff. I just felt he was worth the risk."
Welcome to the big leagues, Mr. Matheny. Oh, by the way, the man who held the job before you is arguably the best manager in at least the last six decades, a virtual lock to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame for the way he handled a game, and leaves a tough act to follow, having led the Cardinals to a World Series championship last October.
So much for challenges.
Here it is, mid-October, and Matheny and the Cardinals are still wearing their uniforms, playing games that count and in position to defend that World Series championship, something no National League team has done since the Big Red Machine of Sparky Anderson in 1975-76.
The Cardinals earned their postseason opportunity as a Wild Card, just like last year, and so far they knocked off Atlanta in a win-or-go-home, one-game Wild Card showdown, and knocked off Washington in the best-of-five NL Division Series by becoming the first team in history to overcome a deficit of more than four runs in a loser-is-eliminated postseason series finale by rallying from a 6-0 deficit in Game 5 on Friday night at Nationals Park to beat Washington, 9-7.
Now they are ready to open the best-of-seven NL Championship Series with San Francisco at AT&T Park on Sunday evening (7 CT on FOX) in a matchup of the last two teams to win the World Series.
Talk about passing the managerial entrance exam.
"I know there's a high level of expectation with this job," Matheny said. "If I didn't think I could handle it, I wouldn't have walked into the interview process."
He actually came in the backdoor of the interview process.
When La Russa told Mozeliak in mid-August last year, put together a list of "35 to 40 candidates," which didn't include Matheny.
"I had him in the back of my mind, over to the side," said Mozeliak. "He was the outlier."
As the list of candidates was whittled down, Mozeliak threw out Matheny's name to owner Bill DeWitt, who found the name intriguing.
Then, Matheny was joining Francona, Sandberg, Oquendo, Triple-A Memphis manager Chris Maloney and Joe McEwing, a former Cardinals player now a coach with the Chicago White Sox, in the interview process.
"When I called him about coming in for the interview, I tried to help him manage the expectations," said Mozeliak. "I told him it would be a good experience that he could get a feel for what the process is like. ... And then he hit a home run."
It was, Mozeliak said, a no-brainer once the interviews were completed. There was no hesitation in taking a chance on the unproven commodity, even with a team where success is expected.
"I understood it is a desirable position, but I also understood I wanted a guy who not only could come in and maintain what we have, but someone who would be a part of our long-term future.
"A lot of people might have felt they needed to put their own fingerprints on this team, but we felt what we do as an organization, we do well. We wanted someone who could come in and continue what we had and build off that, not feel he had to build something different."
There was, after all, little fault to find with the legacy left by La Russa, who got his managerial start with the Chicago White Sox, became a household name in Oakland, who spent 16 of his 33 managerial seasons in St. Louis and managed more games for the Cardinals (2,591) than he did for the White Sox and A's combined (2,506).
"In the interview process, what stood out was he understood the direction we are trying to go," said Mozeliak.
And 11 months later, Matheny has only reaffirmed the confidence Mozeliak had in the hire.
Matheny took a team that lost its offensive catalyst, Albert Pujols, to free agency, didn't have its rotation ace, Chris Carpenter, until the final days of the regular season, but never looked for excuses to fail, always pushing for reasons to succeed.
So far, so good.
Now, if he can just get the Cardinals past the Giants hurdle they are about to face.