With 20 first-place votes and 12 second-place votes, Howard defeated Pujols -- last year's NL MVP -- by a total of 388 to 347. The Astros' Lance Berkman (230) and the Mets' Carlos Beltran (211) finished third and fourth, respectively.
Manager Tony La Russa expressed his support for the ultimate decision, but he couldn't hide his disappointment that another one of his Cardinals missed out on some postseason hardware.
"I would never want to disrespect players who have had outstanding seasons," said La Russa. "I'm not surprised -- not just Howard, but [Arizona Cy Young winner Brandon] Webb, I'm not surprised that they won. They both had outstanding years. But I'm disappointed, because I thought our two guys [Pujols and Chris Carpenter] ... I was hoping, and I was disappointed that they didn't get the awards."
Pujols put up career-best marks in home runs (49), RBIs (137) and slugging percentage (.671), while falling just short of a new personal best in on-base percentage (.431). He was by far the biggest offensive threat on a Cardinals team that edged out the Astros for a division title before roaring to the World Series championship in October. The St. Louis first baseman also picked up his first career Gold Glove.
Still, voters were apparently wowed by about the only two numbers where Pujols finished behind Howard.
The thunderous Phillies masher led not just the NL but the Majors with 58 home runs and 149 RBIs. He also eclipsed Pujols with 108 walks, though he struck out nearly three times as much as Pujols. And while Pujols spent time on the disabled list for the first time in his career, Howard played nearly every day, appearing in 159 games to Pujols' 143.
"The voters have to answer whether they factored in the at-bats that he missed," La Russa said. "But all I know is, you look at his stats, and if you prorate the production ... plus, he had a huge September. But I'm not going to get into it a lot, because Ryan Howard won and he should be congratulated."
Nonetheless, it's a tough one to take for the Cardinals, who leaned heavily on their slugger in a year when some key offensive parts missed big chunks of the season. In each of his six Major League seasons, Pujols has finished fourth or better in MVP voting. Yet he has only won the award once -- last year, when he outdistanced the Braves' Andruw Jones.
At the beginning of the season, it appeared that Pujols would run away with MVP honors. He got off to one of the hottest starts in baseball history, smashing 14 home runs in April. By the end of May he'd gone deep 25 times, and had already racked up 65 RBIs.
However, Pujols suffered a strained oblique muscle on June 3, and was forced to the DL for the first time. He returned on June 21 and went 4-for-4 with a home run in his second game back, then tore through July at a .361 clip with 17 extra-base hits.
By that time, though, Howard had begun his assault on NL pitching in earnest. And by the end of August, Howard was pushing 50 home runs. All this while the Phillies were climbing the Wild Card standings. Meanwhile, the Cardinals faded in September, and though they made the playoffs and Philadelphia did not, the impressions the two clubs generated in September may have colored the vote.
Pujols would have been the first player since Kirk Gibson in 1988 to win the NL MVP in the same year that his team won the World Series. He also would have been only the second Cardinal to win multiple MVP awards, along with Stan Musial.
La Russa, however, didn't let the fact that Pujols and Carpenter fell short of some postseason awards dampen his postseason.
"In the end, both guys, they got their first world championship," he said. "So that counts for everything."
|Voting results ¬|
|Ryan Howard, PHI||20||12||388|
|Albert Pujols, STL||12||19||1||347|
|Lance Berkman, HOU||21||4||3||2||1||1||230|
|Carlos Beltran, NYM||1||5||15||6||2||2||1||211|
|Miguel Cabrera, FLA||2||6||10||5||5||1||2||170|
|Alfonso Soriano, WAS||1||2||4||6||1||7||2||1||106|
|Jose Reyes, NYM||1||1||5||5||3||4||1||2||98|
|Chase Utley, PHI||1||6||7||10||1||1||98|
|David Wright, NYM||1||1||2||2||5||2||3||1||70|
|Trevor Hoffman, SD||2||1||1||1||2||2||7||46|
|Andruw Jones, ATL||1||2||1||5||3||29|
|Carlos Delgado, NYM||1||1||1||2||4||23|
|Nomar Garciaparra, LAD||2||3||4||18|
|Rafael Furcal, LAD||1||3||1||11|
|Garrett Atkins, COL||1||1||2||10|
|Matt Holliday, COL||1||2||3||10|
|Aramis Ramirez, CHC||1||1||5|
|Freddy Sanchez, PIT||2||1||5|
|Chris Carpenter, STL||1||4|
|Chipper Jones, ATL||1||3|
|Mike Cameron, SD||1||2|
|Jimmy Rollins, PHI||1||2|
|Bronson Arroyo, CIN||1||1|
|Jason Bay, PIT||1||1|
|Past winners Complete awards coverage|
Matthew Leach is a reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.